EcoGeek

Which is worse? Hummers or toilet paper?



Americans may have come to the point where average consumers frown upon Hummers, but for some reason, we draw the line at toilet paper. We believe so strongly in three-ply and cottony softness that many of us equate recycled toilet paper with cardboard. Toilet paper pushers from Kimberly Clark to Georgia Pacific tout the higher quality of their soft papers and sales for the high-end brands like Charmin Ultra and Quilted Northern Ultra have increased by 40% in some markets, according to a recent NY Times article.

Greenpeace and the Natural Resources Defence Council are fighting back with campaigns to get Americans to consider the toll of using luxury toilet paper. Greenpeace last week issued a national guide for consumers ranking the toilet tissue brands on the basis of their environmental impact. The guide is available for downloading here.

So how bad is our toilet paper habit, really? The product that we use for less than three seconds extracts a larger ecological consequence than driving Hummers, according to Allen Hershkowitz, a senior scientist at the NRDC. More than 98% of all toilet paper sold here comes from virgin wood. The NRDC's position is that no forest of any kind should be used to make toilet paper and Hershkowitz wants to see toilet paper go the way of incandescent light bulbs — out of the mainstream.

But it may be a hard sell. Americans, who use an average of 23.6 rolls per capita a year — more toilet paper than citizens in other countries — three times more than the average European and 100 times more than the average person in China. Europeans and Latin Americans are also less demanding about the quality of their toilet paper, with up to 40% of toilet paper sold in those markets derived from recycled products.

“I really do think it is overwhelmingly an American phenomenon,” said Hershkowitz. “People just don't understand that softness equals ecological destruction.”

Slowly the message is getting out. At the Kodak Theater last week during the Oscars, all the bathrooms were equipped with only 100% recycled paper. If it's good enough for Mickey Rourke's behind, it should be good enough for yours.

Via Guardian, NRDC
Image Via NY Times

Email IM Bookmark del.icio.us Digg

You do not appear to have Yahoo! Messenger installed. Click here to download and install it.

Email this article

There is a problem with one or more email addresses entered

Enter email addresses, separated by commas.

There is a problem with the email address entered

Email addresses will only be used to email this information on your behalf and will not be used for any marketing purposes.

Alerts

Get an alert for updates:
  • from this author
  • on Cleaning
  • on Paper
  • on Cars
  • on Waste

View All Green Alerts »

comments from our community

Showing 1 - 15 of 46 comments

Post Comment
  • Posted by Tom1100 Sun Mar 15, 2009 4:51pm PDT
    Yea, Mickey Rourke is my "roll" model. I want to be just like him!
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by fellseraphim Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:24pm PDT
    "Hershkowitz wants to see toilet paper go the way of incandescent light bulbs " Does this person realize this would mean doing something which is incredibly unsanitary? Not too many people with any sense of cleanliness are going to be down with handling human waste on a regular basis. Sure you could cover your hands with gloves or something like that instead, but using a new pair of gloves each time would create even worse waste. Toilet paper is a necessary evil.
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by Paul & Brianne S Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:27pm PDT
    not using my hand any time soon
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by jem Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:30pm PDT
    What are we supposed to do?? Go back to drying corn cobs?? This is ridiculus!! Maybe the Chinese like to go around with skid marks in their underwear. And smell like a pig. But I don't! Bring on the Sears catalogs!
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by ROBERT C Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:40pm PDT
    Tp is recycled. Watch "How it is Made" I don't care if it is yesterdays paper, it works for me. If it does the job and I am not injured doing my business,(old days, corn cobs or Sears Catalog)go take a hike.
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by Phyllis Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:56pm PDT
    Trees-A RENEWABLE RESOURCE-Bring on the Charmin!
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by Richard T Sun Mar 15, 2009 6:57pm PDT
    Paper grown for pulp as long as it isn't dyed, a Hummer driven for vanity that is waste without taste!
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by A Realist Sun Mar 15, 2009 7:36pm PDT
    I read another article on this recently, and it seems that the reason virgin lumber is used is due to the fact that the wood fibers are longer, which (somehow) in the process equates to softer fibers than using 2nd (or newer) growth wood. In the article above I didn't see any mention of "using ones hand." I believe the point is, as a whole, Americans are a spoiled people who believe we have a right to anything we want to consume, including Hummers, four ply paper, or whatever it is, environment be damned. This attitude is not commendable, whether it's regarding TP or other environmental issues. I work to leave a better attitude and world to my son, and future generations. This isn't about politics: this is about common sense and leaving a decent future for those who will come after us.
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by jem Sun Mar 15, 2009 8:40pm PDT
    I am old enough to remember back in the 1970's all the 'shortages' that occurred to create panic with consumers. Every other week it was something different. And yes, toilet paper was one of them. Coffee another. You couldn't walk into a grocery store without finding those shelves empty. And who could forget waiting in line for two hours at the gas station? How about the panic to get your hands on a Cabbage Patch doll or a Pound Puppy? Funny there aren't shortages on them now. I think the public has just become weary of all the games these manufacturers play just to hike the price. Greed, greed, greed!!! So now everyone ignores them. Thus people ignore these warnings that we will soon run out of a certain resource or product.
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by Lotus Thu Mar 26, 2009 3:30pm PDT
    Ever driven up the coast through Oregon? I have. It's destroyed and denuded. The logging industry takes what it wants, and leaves a mess of stumps, logs, and heaved earth behind, ruining the land completely with no seeming rhyme or reason. It's sad.
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by chashint Thu Mar 26, 2009 3:49pm PDT
    You know a lot of public rest rooms in the less developed parts of Europe and even more so in Asia simply have a hole in the floor to squat over. In Asia open sewers between the housing to another open sewer that runs beside the street is very common. Away from the city electricity and piped water are scarce. Its not surprising that TP is not something that they would be overly concerned about. Maybe indoor toilets, a clean public water supply, and electricity are the real issues ... it gives us the opportunity to consider that there may be something better than scratchy single ply TP to wipe our rear ends with. My company stocks the rest rooms with the cheapo TP and I along with many others can be seen carrying our own personal favorite to the toilet with us.
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by Roger O Thu Mar 26, 2009 4:37pm PDT
    Personally, I wish all the people who KNOW how I should change my life so that THEIRS gets better would stop using up all MY oxygen and quit breating.
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by deeba a Fri Mar 27, 2009 3:23am PDT
    hey there just a suggestion over here in the Arab countries they use water to clean up rather then toilet what about that
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by lnchunt Fri Mar 27, 2009 4:13pm PDT
    The biggest problem I have with using recycled or eco-friendly products is that they are usually MORE EXPENSIVE than their earth-destroying counterparts.
    Report Abuse
  • Posted by Billie B Fri Mar 27, 2009 4:22pm PDT
    What do they use Europe... maybe the bidet, I always thought that was a good idea. Something I noticed in Europe was the lack of wash clothes in hotel rooms...never new what that was all about. I didn't really notice the tp only the toilets didn't flush. Anyway I never heard of 4 ply toilet paper is that for the uber rich? I agree that tp is a necessary evil and a Hummer is definately waste without taste.
    Report Abuse

Leave a Comment:

You must first sign in.

Green Picks Playlist